77 replies to this topic

[Gust0o]

Evening all - I'm sure this has been suggested before, and I'm only thinking out loud... but what about a minimum post count before members can sell items?

I know there are arguments against this - such as people will just spam pointless posts - but we are seeing more people join the site simply to post Ebay links to their items for sale. I've always imagined the For Sale section being an additional piece of functionality for the community, not some more general or more mercenary service.

BCRichPlayers.com has a similar scheme, requiring a minimum of 50 posts - it's had good feedback to-date.

Thoughts? Am I just being a pedant? Does my bum look big on this?

[LukeFRC]

been talked about a lot before.
I think the problem is that a lot of people do stick stuff up for sale and then stick around.
others just come on, and if they sell something to someone at a good price... I'm not too worried. I've sold to folk who popped up and bought a bass or amp off me and were never seen again. I was pretty careful with new folk, but all round everyone was happy.

[Truckstop]

I sort of want a minmum post limit, but at the same time it's not as if it's a hassle to wade through the occasional ebay link.

I don't know...basically

Truckstop

[Gareth Hughes]

My SpideySense tingles when I see a low or zero post count on a for sale item. That's enough for me to be wary - but then I'm lumping the good in with the bad there.

[Chris2112]

I think it all comes down to your spidey senses? As we may get 'walk in' traffic from people coming to sell stuff who then stick around. It seems as though recently we have had quite an influx of non-UK users, who can be a wealth of information by tuning us in to local music and luthiers who we may not hear about otherwise.

Some new users I would have no issues buying from as they seem quite genuine, I would be less impressed with "hel0, pls by my base, i am selling for my father hu is out of the countryy a tthe minute...plzx wire your funds to me in Nigeria"

[skankdelvar]

The Rick Resource forum* did this a couple of years ago. For those BC-ers who just can't wait for our thread to develop here's a link to their 15 page thread:

http://www.rickresou...p?f=25&t=393488

And the outcome:

Quote

EDIT BY GIL: please note that the (minimum post) number is now 30 and not 100 as originally planned. A word of caution though: nonsense posts (inc multiple +1's) will be removed; the idea behind this restriction is to let forumites get to know the new user better before any financial interaction; boosting your post count for the sake of boosting your post count will get your post deleted and a warning will be issued.

* The unofficial Rick Forum, not Mr Hall's official Rick site. Lovely chaps.

[dannybuoy]

No good would come of this, there would just be more spam on the forum and less things for sale.

[Evil Undead]

dannybuoy, on 24 February 2012 - 07:32 AM, said:

No good would come of this, there would just be more spam on the forum and less things for sale.

I agree with this

[Doctor J]

I think it's a good idea. I see it as something akin to a record shop which only allows its customers put up posters for gigs, not just any passing sh*tehawk looking to spam their goods in as many places as google finds for them. To get something back you must give something first.

You could also put ebay, gumtree and the likes into the swear filter, meaning any such links offsite in the FS forum don't work and, in doing so, are pointless.

You either encourage people to engage with the site and community most of all or they leave it alone, but at least it doesn't get used as a dump.

[Nibody]

Doctor J, on 24 February 2012 - 08:08 AM, said:

You could also put ebay, gumtree and the likes into the swear filter, meaning any such links offsite in the FS forum don't work and, in doing so, are pointless.

But then that would kill the ebay links forum?

[Gust0o]

dannybuoy, on 24 February 2012 - 07:32 AM, said:

No good would come of this, there would just be more spam on the forum and less things for sale.

I doubt it, personally. I think it would simply put the opportunists off at the gate - and I don't think we've seen major problems on the other bass sites operating a similar policy. I don't think it would significantly impede the For Sale forum, which sees a lot of traffic from more regular posters, and hopefully inspire some more confidence in buyers - I'm with my namesake Gareth, in that I start to wonder when the first post is a For Sale item.

What it does do is ensure you've got some reasonably regular posters coming through. You'll still get the walk-through traffic, as people will come to sell their gear as they are now... and then they've got a choice to stay or not; you've got to hope, if they're choosing to stay and meet a modest post count requirement, that they're the ones we genuinely want, who are going to share their knowledge as well as their Ebay links.

You'll have to let us know if this debate is panning out in line with the Ric forum experience, Skank - I expect so

Edited by Gust0o, 24 February 2012 - 10:15 AM.

[discreet]

Evil Undead, on 24 February 2012 - 07:48 AM, said:

I agree with this

I agree with that.

[discreet]

...There's a forum especially for Rickenbackers??

[flyfisher]

I agree with the sentiment but I think it's not quite so simple in practice.

I agree with the earlier comment about a post count of '1' in the for sale section setting off the warning bells. I'd probably not do a deal with a newbie unless it was face to face. Not entirely rational, I know, but there we are.

[Earbrass]

I do find it annoying when newbies post their stuff for sale and then bump their ads several times a day - I see that as disrespectful to other forum users.

[Gust0o]

No moderator comment?

[throwoff]

I actually agree with this, and set it quite low, 20, maybe 30 posts.

Thats not a mountain to climb really, quick thread in introductions, comment on a bassist/bass/amp or two and they will be there.

[soopercrip]

I don't think a minimum post is necessary.
If your buying from a newbie on here or ebay it is a case of 'buyer beware', and using your own judgement.
I reckon it would deter people from joining the forum and would be a loss.

Andy

[Lozz196]

I remember joining Basschat back in 2010, purely to sell a bass. That was some 3000 posts ago (and what seems like 3000 sales/purchases). I can see why people may be wary of buying from a newbie, but as long as photos are good, comms don`t give you any warning-signs, and you use Paypal, it really is a case of using your own judgement as to whether you go ahead with the purchase.

Would be interesting to put up a poll - in fact I may do it later - on how many members joind with their first intention being selling an item.

[skankdelvar]

Gust0o, on 24 February 2012 - 10:14 AM, said:

You'll have to let us know if this debate is panning out in line with the Ric forum experience, Skank - I expect so

Pretty much, except we've covered most of the key points and POV's in one page. They spent another 14 pages going round in circles. I hope we don't.

discreet, on 24 February 2012 - 10:36 AM, said:

...There's a forum especially for Rickenbackers??

Yes, and very nice it is too. Like us, but less rowdy and less given to modifying their instruments.

Lozz196, on 29 February 2012 - 12:33 PM, said:

how many members joind with their first intention being selling an item.

I did.

Personally, I'm not in favour of a post count. IMO, someone who joins just to trade will miss out on the badinage and useful info. But that's their choice and I'm not offended by it.

And one might argue there are long-term BC-er's who contribute materially to the community by quietly getting on with selling (or buying) choice bits of gear to the rest of us.

As for the security aspect, sure there have been some noob scammers. But there have equally been some longer-term members here who've strayed off the path either by design or neglect.

So post count isn't an infallible discriminator. Like many people here, I tend to shy away from buying from low-post count noobs (NOI), thus one might contend that an informal system is already in place.

Edited by skankdelvar, 29 February 2012 - 06:52 PM.