Jump to content
Why become a member? ×

Keys? Workstation, Keys & DAW or something else???


xgsjx
 Share

Recommended Posts

I'm not playing in a band anymore. Last time I played with my band was January & we've not been doing much at all.
Considered trying to get things back up & running & my singer took a stroke (literally. There's a thread in OT). There's only guitarists in Perth, no musicians available at all.
I'm finding playing bass without a band seriously boring (with a band it's excellent) & think I might have finally came to the decision to sell all my gear & go back to keys, but what to get is a hard decision.

So as a lot of you guys have experience with these sort of things, I'm gonna ask for some help & advice.

Here's my options that I've seen so far...

Workstation - I'm really liking the Korg Krome 73.

Synth - Something like the Roland Juno Stage, & get a 1/2 decent DAW to run the sequencing.

Keys & rack (s) - Should I get a 88 key remote keyboard (Studiologic Acuna or M Audio) & a rack synth & maybe use GarageBand for sequencing).

Keys & DAW - Get an 88 key remote & Reason 6 (or similar).

I want to be able to sit & play keys (like just piano on it's own) & also be able to write & record songs on it. Is a DAW with a VSTi going to be as good as something like the Korg for sitting playing? Is there other options that I haven't thought about (like getting loads of 2nd hand gear from 10 years ago)?
I want to try & keep things under £1k.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wouldn't go for the controller keyboard + computer option - I think it would be a pain to have to boot up a computer every time you just want to play the piano, and you'd probably end up playing it less as a result.

There are so many variables here it's hard to know what to advise; personally, I have a very old Yamaha electric piano (bought second-hand in the late 1980's) which has a lovely weighted keyboard, but crap sounds and which weighs a ton, plus a cheap secondhand MIDI module for the bread and butter sounds, and a computer DAW for recording/sequencing. This means when I just want to sit and play I just turn on the piano and module, but I have more sounds available in the computer for when I'm composing/arranging/recording. The module cost me about £150 on ebay, and I think I'd struggle to give the piano away, so maybe you could pick up something similar cheap.

Do you want to keep open the option of playing keys in a band? If so, consider portability and weight - properly weighted keyboards are much heavier, and a full 88 note board can be awkward to fit into cars (76 notes is a good compromise).

Are you a piano player or more into synth and organ sounds? For serious piano playing, weighted keys give a much better feel - but for organ/synth playing it can be a disadvantage.

[quote name='xgsjx' timestamp='1351635666' post='1853644']
There's only guitarists in Perth, no musicians available at all.
[/quote]

:lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Earbrass' timestamp='1351675897' post='1853939']
I wouldn't go for the controller keyboard + computer option - I think it would be a pain to have to boot up a computer every time you just want to play the piano, and you'd probably end up playing it less as a result.

There are so many variables here it's hard to know what to advise; personally, I have a very old Yamaha electric piano (bought second-hand in the late 1980's) which has a lovely weighted keyboard, but crap sounds and which weighs a ton, plus a cheap secondhand MIDI module for the bread and butter sounds, and a computer DAW for recording/sequencing. This means when I just want to sit and play I just turn on the piano and module, but I have more sounds available in the computer for when I'm composing/arranging/recording. The module cost me about £150 on ebay, and I think I'd struggle to give the piano away, so maybe you could pick up something similar cheap.

Do you want to keep open the option of playing keys in a band? If so, consider portability and weight - properly weighted keyboards are much heavier, and a full 88 note board can be awkward to fit into cars (76 notes is a good compromise).

Are you a piano player or more into synth and organ sounds? For serious piano playing, weighted keys give a much better feel - but for organ/synth playing it can be a disadvantage.
[/quote]

Cheers. :D

I'm not planning on playing in a band again, but I wouldn't fully rule it out. Length isn't an issue with my car if I do need to take it out the house.

I'm liking your idea of keys, module & DAW. Or maybe a Roland Juno Stage & a DAW?

I was mainly a synth player. I'm more used to playing on synth keys (semi weighted), but I've played a bit of piano recently & enjoyed it.

Listened to the piano sounds on the Korg Krome & they're superb. Both the Korg & the Roland are 73 key semi weighted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...