Jump to content
Why become a member? ×

Tuning in 5ths


ubassman
 Share

Recommended Posts

Anyone experimented with tuning in 5ths á la Joel Quarrington? Certainly an interesting alternative to the fingering positions used to navigate the fingerboard tuned in 4ths (and actually nothing new).

Young bass player Tomoya Aomori is exploring this as an interactive project inviting participants via his web site [url="http://www.playthe5bass.com"]http://www.playthe5bass.com[/url] Full of downloads, ideas, etudes and media.

It may not be so user friendly an idea for many especially given the easy transition of tuning in 4ths from horizontal BG to vertical EUB/DB but an entirely different approach to playing the DB based on cello pedagogy . Here's a vid below from Barrie Kolstein master luthier explaining why for classical music it makes a lot of sense and he also suggests that from a luthiers point of view 5th tuning brings some instruments to life.

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79xJC3EP8VY[/media]


The tuning is to fit the bass with a low C, followed by a G, D, A ( at least the D string doesnt change from 4th tuning!). ;)

Edited by ubassman
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd love to try it one day. Fourths work at the moment but it does seem like it would make more sense to tune in fifth's when playing with an orchestra.

It does seem to be more work for bassists to stay in tune with the orchestra then anyone else. You see whole sections make faces as they slip out of tune.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 9 months later...

old thread, but I've just started re-learning bass in fifths tuning. Bought a set of Red Mitchell strings (I first tried retuning my regular EADG set but not that playable)

I came to try fifths after learning pivot shifting. I played orchestral bass to a decent standard at school, learning a solid Simandl technique. Gave up playing age 19. Then a couple of years back age 40 I got the urge to play again and got a stagg EDB. happily I found I soon got my old technique back. Then I spent hours googling on all things Double Bass to find out what had progressed in the last 21 years and discovered Rabbath and pivot shifting. Learned to pivot shift - watched Rabbaths DVDs and worked through the Vance books. Along the way I discovered that folk like Joel were tuning in fifths and with the new range I had with pivot shifting, realised that playing in fifths was completely possible.

What I mean by 'possible' is that on the top G string I can stretch to C# with my 4th finger while keeping thumb in 1st position. With my old technique I would have been shifting all over the place.

It's early days but so far the biggest hurdle is going to be the sight reading - relearn where all the notes are. In terms of playing by ear I find fifths a bit more logical.

Relearning all the notes is just a matter of time spend sight-reading until I can do it instinctively.

So in summary my advice to anyone wanting to play in fifths, just get started as there's a lot practice required.

My motivation for Learning fifths as that so much of the orchestral repertoire suits 5ths better than 4ths.You need a C extension on a regular bass to be able to play 'anything' in an orchestra, and I didn't get on with a C extension. and my hands are a bit small for a 5 string.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting concept... here's a possible workable way to utilise both tunings ? : [url="http://store.hipshotproducts.com/cart.php?m=product_detail&p=373"]http://store.hipshot...ct_detail&p=373[/url]

The video on the link at time 0:55 shows using this device to change from 4th's tuning to 5th's tuning.

I've just bought one of these & www.LaurenceDixon.com is currently fitting one for me on the low E string so I don't have to get a C-Extension - I'm a jazz player & have been playing with a saxophone ensemble recently (27 piece band)... lot's of flat keys, so I need to play low Db's & Eb's. Have been sight reading these low notes with my 5 string electric bass as transposing them up an octave doesn't always work. Thought one of these devices would do the job in regards getting me to the low notes quickly when changing songs.

After reading : [url="http://www.playthe5bass.com/strings/"]http://www.playthe5bass.com/strings/[/url] am thinking there could be an issue getting a nice string set-up that will work for changing between 4th's & 5th's tuning, especially if using a HipShot Xtender like in my first link ?

Edited by Paul Galbraith
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...