[quote name='wateroftyne' post='393549' date='Jan 28 2009, 11:49 AM']Personally, I think it's the[i] placement [/i]of the pup as much as the pup itself. You could stick a P-pup, a Single-coil or a DarkStar in there and it's still going to lack definition..[/quote]
I have a P with a Jazz pickup in the neck postion, its pretty bassy, but not totally lacking definition. Well, the tuning to A doesn't help definition, but when it had sensible strings and tuning, its was still ok.