Dad3353

To get the ball rolling... [url="https://soundcloud.com/dad3353/albertis-last-waltz"]Alberti's Last Waltz (Slightly Faded...) ...[/url] Enjoy.

[quote name='NancyJohnson' timestamp='1496343506' post='3310758'] In no particular order... [/quote] Some very good'uns there; I doubt, however, that Terry Bozzio would have been a better fit than Ringo for the Beatles, any more than Ringo would have been good in the Mothers. He (Ringo...) needs no defence from me; his style was more than suitable at the time for what was required, and stands the test of time, as long as one keeps context in mind. Was/is he a 'sh1t' drummer..? Not at all, but I can see why you fail to see any qualities in his work. There's no accounting for taste; to each his/her own.

[quote name='NancyJohnson' timestamp='1496338697' post='3310715']... He just doesn't/didn't seem to have a clue. [/quote] Somewhat summary as a critique, I'd say. I suppose we are to gather that you don't like something about his style. And your drumming heroes are..?

[quote name='DaveFry' timestamp='1496325037' post='3310533'] I have always assumed "comping" was a abbreviation for accompanying as in :- During the flood grandma floated away on the grand piano and grandpa accompanied her on the double bass . Carry on OT. [/quote] That's my interpretation, too, but I believe there's local variation, and sometimes, context breeds differing uses of the same term.

[quote name='NancyJohnson' timestamp='1496332951' post='3310639'] No, you misunderstood. I was using the Ringo element as a metaphor, much in the same way as GH only got a song or two. I know full well it's a Harrison tune...my mumma didn't raise me as a mouth-breather. [/quote] OK, as you were. Just struck me as odd, s'all. Carry on regardless...

[quote name='Mornats' timestamp='1496332866' post='3310638'] Oh great pic! [/quote] +1 I hear an Alberti bass coming on...

[quote name='NancyJohnson' timestamp='1496324320' post='3310513'] I remember a bloke I used to play with always said that they [i]had [/i]to give Ringo a song, more out of sympathy than anything else, but for love of [i]whatever [/i]where were their heads at to include [i]Within You Without You[/i] on the album?... [/quote] Ringo Starr..? [url="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Within_You_Without_You"]Wikipedia: Within You Without You ...[/url]

[quote name='Monkey Steve' timestamp='1496322020' post='3310485'] in fairness that is from a drummer, sorry, drumber, so the fact he can even hold a pencil puts him in the advanced class [/quote]

[quote name='NancyJohnson' timestamp='1496316467' post='3310416']...with the exception of [i]Within You Without You[/i]. It just ruins the flow of the album and had my finger hovering over the fast forward botton. Shockingly awful. [/quote] One had to 'be there'.

All of this, although technically fascinating, is, in my view, complete overkill for domestic, amateur use. Of course, if one can do more, one can do less, so it's all useful info, but it's going to be a long time before I need more than my i5 proc or SSD. Not knocking it; if I was Cresus I'd probably bite the bullet, but my meagre resources don't spread to these 'cutting edge' techniques. I don't feel handicapped at all by my modest 'lean' system. Just sayin'.

[quote name='KevB' timestamp='1496308497' post='3310342'] Disraeli gears Surrealistic Pillow The Doors/Strange Days Are You Experienced/Axis Bold As Love Procol Harum Piper At The Gates Of Dawn There must have been something in the water... [/quote] Snap, so +1. Yes, I still listen to all of those with great pleasure (as well as more recent, and much older (Schubert..? Bruckner..?) stuff...). It's all good, but special mention for 'Surrealistic Pillow'. S'been a long time comin'; s'gonna be a long time gone.

33..? Some of us here are already twice that..!

[left][size=4][color="#222222"][font="Arial, sans-serif"][size=4]And the winner is... WILD FROG SHOT..! [sharedmedia=core:attachments:167486] Here, then, is your Winner's Certificate (download and save as pdf file, then proudly print and frame...) ...[/size][/font][/color] [attachment=246375:BC_Chal_Cert_2017_05.pdf] [color="#222222"][font="Arial, sans-serif"][size=4]... which looks like this (but bigger, of course..!)… [/size][/font][/color][/size][/left]

[quote name='Skol303' timestamp='1496268878' post='3310168'] How wrong you are... [/quote] Gets my vote; his best work yet. Still not enough cowbell, however.

[quote name='Meddle' timestamp='1496253838' post='3309999'] I'm watching this now in iPlayer.... [/quote] +1 Post of the week. Excellent review, spot on in all respects. Respect.

[quote name='MoonBassAlpha' timestamp='1496252680' post='3309983'] Have I missed something here? What's mr. smalls done? [/quote] You're new here, then..?

[quote name='SH73' timestamp='1496245521' post='3309906'] I'm really struggling to vote. Every song has something unique about them. Would it be fair to say I'll give my vote to the three that received lesser votes? [/quote] The criteria for attribution of your vote are entirely up to you. There is no 'Skol Force' about to swoop down on those deigning to ignore the suggestions, despite all his bravado and bluster. Do as you think best, decide how you wish, invoke the hidden Punk in you, and be satisfied that you've made at least someone happier. 'Does it fit the picture..?' was the original notion, but we've come a long way down the anarchy trail since then ([i]sic [/i]Lenny. and a few other rebels..). Feel free, old chum; feel free...

[quote name='Monkey Steve' timestamp='1496237110' post='3309791'] see this this is exactly why it became a running joke that means I'll always use the wrong spelling... [/quote] It's taken me several years to get used to 'teh', or 'TIM' (and I still wake at nights, mumbling and shivering, at times...), and now there's a new one to provoke ripples in this millpond. Oh, well...

[quote name='lowdown' timestamp='1496236436' post='3309782']... Have you ever thought of putting together a series of videos regarding this, as a sticky, maybe ?... [/quote] Modesty forbids it.

... and no-one will get hurt. Here's the stuff; just do it, you know it makes sense... [url="http://basschat.co.uk/topic/306259-may-composition-challenge-voting/page__view__findpost__p__3309723"]Skol's Reminder ...[/url] Pop to the Top and chill out.

[quote name='Monkey Steve' timestamp='1496234130' post='3309756']...and find that I'm still doing it... [/quote] WELL, DAMN WELL STOP IT..! ...

Am I allowed to pedantically suggest that it should be 'cue', as in 'that's when to come in', rather than 'queue', where one waits in line to get served..? Just sayin', no malice intended.

[quote name='Fabrocker' timestamp='1496169998' post='3309332']... Don't know how to make YouTube window... [/quote] [media]http://youtu.be/GrmnwyqK9hg[/media] Remove the 's' from the 'https' at the beginning of the link, s'all. Nice solo, too; not too long..!

[quote name='Skol303' timestamp='1496148574' post='3309119']If you don't run Reason, you need Reason [/quote] I'll consider this once I've worked out what Reason can do for me that Reaper can't, and I have €369 spare. That may well not be next week.