Well, i gig almost exclusively with A brubaker 6 string lol...
I must admit that in most case it just goes great and I rarely get any bad comments.
I think bands sometimes have a really strict view of what/how they should look. Recently I got told "if you want that job, Precision bass sunburst would be the one. Altough I know my brubaker kicks ass to most other basses around, but I do not wanna be seen as the egotistical one who turns down jobs cuz it's not the "right bass". So in the end I got a P5 lol. Works great. In the end any bassist needs about 6 basses to cover anything really. One or two "classic looking" thing. And maybe then modern basses. Cause you never know what you will bump into, and I don't know many people who can afford to turn down work anyways... lol ...
Anyway, I still hate fenders... lol.. They are so many alternative these days to those classic design, to me and my taste, they don't make any sense anymore....