Although I love messing around with effects, I don't need them very often for my cover band gigs. Typically I might want chorus, or distortion, or octaver for just a few songs. My small pedalboard spent most of the gig idle.
Last year I replaced it with a Line 6 HX One: all the Helix effects, most of which are very good, an easy to use UI, and a tuner in a small box that fits in my gig bag and takes up no space on a cramped stage. A lot of people dismissed it as poor value as it only provides one effect at a time but for me it's ideal.