Bilbo

Agreed. When I was a young player, I used to transcribe Jeff Berlin parts and could play them. Joe Frazier. Bach, Marabi, Motherlode, Five G. Then there was Teen Town, Silly Putty etc etc. Could execute them all. It was then that I realised that execution of complex music was a million miles away from creating it. HAVING the ideas is much harder than playing them.

I think that jazz suffers somewhat from an identity crisis in as much as different people have massively different perspectives on what 'the point of it all' actually is. I am often appalled at what some people, a, think is Jazz and how, b, they assess content. I am not setting myself up as the guru who has the inside line on the definition of Jazz but a lot of people seem to get off on what I call the athletes and jugglers who do remarkable things with various techniques but which lack any musical substance. Double bass has generally avoided that tendency thankfully and most players actually play rather than do tricks but the audience expectations for supercharged athleticism remains a potential distraction.

Great thread. Inspirational in itself. For me, the 'secret', and it is not a secret at all, is to study things properly and not to dip in and out without properly dealing with the thing you have chosen to look at. I have two example. On double bass, I got a bow when I got a double bass and have never 'studied' it until fairly recently when I picked up the bow and the Neil Tarlton book. I spent a few days.weeks working on the bow for a few minutes a day (20?) and, before I knew it, I was actually playing the thing. Same with double thumbing. I am not a slap fan but, like many bass players, I feel the need to stay on top of new things. I tried double thumbing a few years ago and didn't make much of it and I only return to it for a few moments every now andthen but, the other day, I started playing something and it was there. My incremental input had borne fruit. I use reading as a means of generating practive pieces. BAch Cello Suites are a rich vein for practice and inspiration. Transcriptions of solos of any kind. Even other solo transcriptions to bass; they are often transcribed in a different key to bass but you can still practice them in the wrong key and learn (I read treble clef also so this is easier for me). Try looking for new players, new genres etc. Personally, and I mean this, there is nothing more inspirational that a straight quarter note walking bass line. If all else fails, I just walk a blues with NO accents, just straight quarter notes. Lush!!!

For me, it was Jon Anderson all the way.

Practice reading.

I have a seven string I tune BEADGBE. Think a guitar with a low B.

It's one of the things I love about Jazz. The age thing means zilch. I have played with 75 years olds (Peter King, Art Themen etc) who SO kicked my butt it's unreal.

My head is elsewhere this month but here is something to show willing!! https://soundcloud.com/robert-palmer-1/hurricane

I loved this band when I was a teenager but, frankly, they haven't travelled well!!

Systematic approaches work best in the long run. The more chaotic approaches often end up being the long way around.

I struggle with transitions. I get a great riff or chord sequence, add layers of melody and counterpoint and then fail to find any form of middle eight, interlude or sequence. It all ends up feeling samey. My thoughts are, maybe if I think about it a little longer....

Your descriptions mirror my own experiences, Pop. I have hundreds of Curate files, Sibelius charts or good ol' fashioned manuscript paper stuffed into drawers, guitar cases and box files, just waiting for the next flicker of inspiration.

John Paul Jones Charles Minus John Patitucci

I don't cry at music but am moved by so much; too many to list.

I try so hard to get something going compositionally and get frustrated a lot at what I don't achieve. I have done a lot of reading (and thinking) on the issue and it is apparent that many, many composers, at the highest possible levels (Maria Sshneider, Steve Swallow etc), spend days, weeks and months (even years) looking at a piece they are working on to try to squeeze something beautiful out of an idea. I know that one of the issues that non-professional musicians are aware of is how much time the pros spend practising (the 'ten hours a day' that Janek Gwizdala talks about etc). It is apparent that the same can be said for composing. I sit in my studio and stare at the computer/guitar/bass/whatever for a few minutes or hours and think 'nothing is happening' because I don't walk away from a finished composition. Why would I? If Maria Schneider agonises over two bars for weeks, why would I expect to nail everything in one sitting? I know there are always stories about songs that were written in half an hour or whatever but those aren't the kinds of things I want to write. I guess I just need to be more patient and let ideas flourish at their own speed. No-one ever hears the damn things anyway

[quote name='Norm' timestamp='1458250371' post='3006084'] me too! My nearest big venue as a teen. UFO, motorhead, rush, msg, ac/dc with bon etc. We must have been at a lot of the same gigs! [/quote] Saxon, Jon Anderson (Song of Seven tour), Trust, Gillan.. it seemed like there was a great gig every week. These were the days when tours were 30 or 40 dates long.

Uli Jon Roth, The Railway, Ipswich. It actually hurt so I watched the gig from the side of the stage kind of behind the PA.

I used to watch all the touring bands there when I was a teenager. Iron Maiden with Paul Dianno, Trust. Diamond Head, April Wine.. I can't remember many of them it was so long ago but I always loved the venue.

It's an interesting question. I would like to know if any bands have broken up, the parties STUDIED music and then, when they reformed, were better. I suspect not. Jazz acts rarely reform as the idea is mostly to keep moving forward but there have been a few reunions 'for old times sake'. My favourite is the trio of Sam Rivers, Dave Holland and Barry Altschul. Their 'Reunion' album is superb.

City Boy - 5705

The trouble with Jazz Festivals is that they often need to employ every pa company and sounding in the region and so many of them have never had to mike up a jazz band before, let alone a double bass. Sound is often of a questionable standard.

The Monkees?

There are two solo double bass albums by Dave Holland. So that's half a market

I spent a lot of time with Al DiMeola' s picking technique book and my pick technique is now better than most guitarist!

There is wisdom in there, EB. Wisdom.