I'm just happy to get the correct notes in the correct places most of the time. Nor do I have a lot of effects to choose from - just varying degrees of OD and a harmoniser (which does a variety of things, but is mostly used as an auto downtuner, or as an octave doubler - we only have a single guitarist so some songs sound better with me having the octave above)
For Wishing Well, it's neck pickup (if there's a choice), tone wound down, OD on, probably at its mildest setting - just want a bit of grit. I dunno how "faithful" that is to the original, but at least it sounds like I paid some attention to it
The OD in question is in my Joyo Monomyth, but any appropriately set OD will do the job I reckon. I like OD pedals that have a couple of degrees of severity available at the flick of a switch, punters don't want to see me fiddling with knobs for five minutes between each song. "This is a heavy one" - flick a switch, job done.