[quote name='Schnozzalee' timestamp='1373921566' post='2143288']
I'd try a Nitro guitar first, I found it an awfully 'crumbly' finish that marks extremely easily - I hear no difference between nitro & poly.
[size=4]I like to look after my stuff obsessively, so I prefer poly because it doesn't mark up, stays looking new & is much less sticky on my hands/forearm - no dings!! So holds the (modern) instrument's value better.[/size]
[/quote]
I had an original finish 1961 Jazzmaster in Olympic White with gold hardware and it was just a lovely thing. Properly roadworn, with dings marks, lots of finish wear and it just felt like it had lived.
I want to start to recreate this with my next bass.
I foolishly sold the Jazzmaster for peanuts in the mid 1990's