[quote name='charic' timestamp='1344600351' post='1766908']
I think guitarchat and drumchat are different forums rather than an extension of this one.
[/quote]
So entirely seprate websites and different URLs, I gather? Then I see no problem with diluting the audience, TBH.
IMO, it's good to have a higher number of moderators. It makes me feel safer, so to speak - at any given moment you can now see that at least four mods/admins are logged on (in the list at the bottom of the home page), so you know that if anything goes amiss (spam attack, trolls etc.) it will be noticed and acted upon very quickly.
As for the choosing process, as a relative newbie I'm fine with that - I assume a good deal of thought has gone into picking long-standing, respected members of the community. However, I also see the point of those other long-standing, respected members who have not been chosen or even asked. But of course, you can't have 20,000 mods/admins and a few hundred ordinary members - a selection needs to be made somehow.