My band play typical indie/punk/guitar anthemic band covers. 2 guitars, bass and drums. At gigs we often get people asking if we can play X, Y or Z usually similar genres. At last nights gig however, a girl comes up and asks....could you play Never too much by Luther Vandross!!!
Now that's a great song but given Luther had one of the best ever soul voices, and the arrangement etc, that was never happening.
What the weirdest request you've had?