When I started my band I specifically said that I didn't want to play indie/pop rock type stuff (Stereophonics, Oasis, the View & so on). Nothing wrong with that genre, I like to listen to it, but I really don't want to play it as I find the plodding basslines a bit mind numbing.
So we have a new singer & I said to him on the band's Facebook convo "any songs you want to sing between writing", so we can play something between writing.
He suggested Superstition (Stevie Wonder). Good song, but the 2 guitarists then said it's a keys song, it'll sound rubbish on guitar & then one suggested Local Boy (Stereophonics).
I explained that I really don't want to be in an indie band & play that sort of stuff unless we can rework it into our own style (which is more a mix of rock, funk, house & fusion. So completely different from the plod of indie).
The drummer then chiped in saying that we shouldn't cover a song the same as the original & we should put our own style on it, which I agree with.
We're gonna do both songs.
So what I'm asking here is if anyone has changed a song's style completely?