[quote name='BassTractor' timestamp='1339363636' post='1687586']
Now I've done some thinking, and sadly I have a hard time really understanding where you're coming from. Already being a guitarist and being able to play some rather demanding stuff, whilst being fairly lost at making bass parts (if I understood you correctly) to me seems like a possible case of demanding too much of yourself and of the formal correctness of your bass parts.
But I'll give it a go, at the risk of condescendence, and of hitting
If I'm correct though, I think a theoretical approach is counterproductive here. In that case, I think you rather need experience in hearing that things can work without a load of formal demands being answered.
As to a pedagogical approach in this, here's what I propose:
As others have said, start with listening to songs in the same style and how bass parts are done.
When playing yourself, go through a quick process if needed (as per your question):
- Use root tones to begin with.
- Make rhythmic patterns with the root, and then also with its octave.
- Exchange tones for other tones, trying to avoid the fifth (a fifth is no statement - a sixth is)
- Soon you should have nice snippets that you can just use as they are.
- Echo small elements from other parts: a rhytmic element, some intervals (also diminish or augment them - play with this), a melody snippet, etc.
- You have ears. So if it sounds good, it is good, at least for the time being.
Just tell me if I have been an idiot. I'm very open to the idea that I hit the wrong ball in the wrong court, and sent it the wrong way to boot.
[/quote]
I think you've done a brilliant job of getting all the vital bits of what everyone has said & making them logical.
Now you know what to do, have fun. That's the important bit!