[quote name='skankdelvar' timestamp='1414879465' post='2594382']
Let us examine the bare bones of Mr Daltrey's contention:
* That the world is in a sh*t state
* That mainstream popular music at one time raged against global sh*ttiness
* That mainstream popular music [i]no longer[/i] rages against global sh*ttiness
* An example of a 'popular, not raging against global sh*ttiness' musical ensemble is One Direction
All pretty much true facts, them.
By contrast the author of the opinion piece re-writes Mr Daltrey's contention, tangentially addressing the entirely unvoiced issue of whether there has been any 'good' music since 1974, instancing as a rebuttal:
[i]New Wave, Grunge, Michael Jackson’s entire solo career, Radiohead, Pulp, Bjork, Beyoncé, Whitney Houston, Amy Winehouse, St Vincent, Prince[/i]
I imagine that - in seeking inspiration - the op-ed author Ms Lindy West merely turned her head to scan the rows of compilation CD's stacked on her living room shelf before enumerating the quintessential list of 'music for girls of a homely appearance who don't really like music and who frequently spend their evenings sobbing into a Paddington Bear pillowcase'.
The acid test is very simple: with whom would one prefer to spend an evening sinking a few beers and talking about music:
i) Roger Daltrey - or (ii) Lindy West, op-ed writer for the Guardian?
I think the answer is pretty clear.
[/quote]
Nope, answer iii) Skankdelvar.