Wrong? It’s not black and white like that surely, just different? The white P I posted above came to me like that and as it was a ‘63, refinishing it was out of the question. It played great and sounded great too.
I’ve never achieved any substantial wear on a bass that I’ve owned from new, just the odd knock, scratch and swirl.
Anyway, perhaps less debate as to the merits of RW or how it was achieved (or not), pics are what the OP is after, therefore…