andruca

Is the question really "active or passive?" or should it be "why no active?"? Is there anyone "shunning" every passive bass? After 36 years of playing bass I've owned and own many of both. I still can't give a conclusive answer. What I'm sure is I don't like basses that sound generic. And I happen to find more active basses that sound so than passive. That said, out of the 12 basses I own nowadays 4 are active: 2 Stingray5s, a MarkBass GV5 (as gnarly a Jazz Bass in active mode as passive) and an Ibanez EHB-1005MS (with alnico Wilkinson pickups replacing the stock Bart BH2s, 1st time I've dealt with the generic sounding issue without selling a bass, I like it that much). I don't think it's a question of active vs. passive but of the higher chance there is of messing up the tone the "longer" the circuitry and overall options/variables involved. There will be active circuitry (and not just the cheapest) that will kill the tone/feel/responsiveness a bass can give, there's noisy circuitry, there's wrong EQ frequency point/curve choices for the particular instrument and/or pickups, there's "curious" voicings, etc. I'm just guessing more combinations could equate to more chances to screw up, thus probably a higher % of negative experiences with active bass guitars, resulting in the notion in some players' minds "blacklisting" active instruments.

Thanks so much 👍 Not as killer as Mike's. Not sure how sounds on a variety of devices, was trying to make it both thick, crunchy and clear enough. I was lucky enough to watch the man himself (with his Yamaha TRB) play the whole intro mashed up with Duke's end a few meters in front of me (2 hours of -teary on my part- eye contact with him, Daryl Stuermer and Phil Collins). Was the intro to their farewell tour show at the Chicago Bulls' stadium in 2021. This is the first Genesis song ever played at my home (my dad brought Duke home the moment it was available in Argentina). Me and my 3 siblings (38 to 47 y/o back then, living in different parts of the world) were all there. Unforgettable ❤️

TOUGH song 😓

There was also the Ibanez Paul Grey (Slipknot) signature ATK. Basically an ATK-300 with widened nut slots.

I've done it so far with many of my 4 strings: Jazz, my Yamahas (SBV-500, SB500S). I even punked the crap out of a (30.5" scale) Epiphone Viola strung BEAD for years, it just worked. 100% pick,with plenty of crunch and compression. Just pick a 4 string you like and start with that. As others point out, experiment with string gauges for a low B with authority. Just consider a bridge pickup always helps with low B articulation.

Congrats 👏👏👏 Looks nice, well taken care of. Thumbs are not my thing, but a good reunion story definitely is, so THUMBS UP 👍👍 Rock it even harder this time 🤘

I haven't off of eBay, but I've bought the cheapest 20 fret neck and (basswod) JB body I could find on AliExpress for 51€ BOTH delivered home in 2019. So mine is probably bottom of the bottom quality. Neck (23€ IIRC) is decent, if a little on the thick side for a JB. It already came with a Fender headstock shape. It adjusts perfectly, just had minimal sharp fret ends I easily filed. No issues whatsoever in 5 years. Since then the offer has blossomed and prices haven't gone too far up. You can get really nice necks for 50-100€. And judging by what can be read around, quality has gone up. My rat rod JB (with all other parts from a donor wreckage I got for 38€ more) came out great. I even recorded a couple of my band's tunes with it.

I've never owned a 6 string and have only played a few. I don't know what I'd do with one. And still it IS tempting for the Jazz Bass lover in me. I think it sounds way better in the video from Empire Music (clearer and more detailed high end) then in Lobster's (harsher highs). Despite what Anthony (EM) claims, I really like how the neck pickup sounds soloed, at least the way he plays it 👍

I wonder how the neck profile on those feels (graphite reinforced slim C, as per specs).

So, this is how my EHB1005MS ended. You might find this radical. I couldn't stand the new EXPENSIVE Bartolinis either, no matter how I coil tapped them (dead sounding, exactly as the factory BH2s and every other Bartolini I've ever owned/played). Not dumping any more dough on them, they're going to the black list, to make DEADlano company, sorry to all fanboys, SPECIALLY FRUSTRATED (and out a lot of money) with both brands. Got a set of alnico Wilkinsons (WBJ5 model) for 54€ delivered home (P452Js, my 4th Bartolini set, were little under 500€ new from the US after delivery and customs). Simply put my EHB has never sounded better, difference is abysmal. Now, let me describe DEAD as in no damm punch, no articulation, no responsiveness to touch, no mids/hi-mids at all, resulting in the annihilation of the zone where tone personality lives. Bartolinis have systematically made any bass I've ever played/owned with them into bland and generic sound. And no, it's not bass humbuckers I have a problem with. My main basses are Musicman and I own and play P basses a lot. Guess when we talk bass humbuckers Leo got that right first time too (twice, 50 and 70 years ago). Not only that, his designs have been copied to exhaustion, with all kinds of diverging or plain cheap specs, without them sounding dead, so no excuse really for dead sounding bass humbuckers, no matter how many "pros" and "boutique" basses equip Bartolinis, that's argumentun ad verecundiam, so not an argument at all. I've had them precariously installed for a couple weeks, testing different positions, and yesterday it was time to 3D print some covers for them. My brother did 99% of it really (CAD work, also owns the printer). My 1% contribution was just fitting. First tried with the Wilkinson covers on. But I wanted the pickups as further from the bridge as possible, so I ended up using the bare pickups under the new covers. Pickups are held with pieces of EVA here and there to keep them centered and pushed towards the neck inside the covers. Didn't want to go all in with a hot glue gun, so I'm able to disassemble them if I wanna make any change. They perfectly keep the ramp in place too (which the P452Js, same size according to Bartolini, didn't, thanx to "crappy tolerances, by Bartolini"). Most important, I have owned and own many Jazz Bass pickups, these Wilkinson WBJ5s (some 20€ more expensive than the usually seen/used ceramic ones) sound GREAT, real open, punchy, articulated, balanced across the whole spectrum, lively and responsive. I'll definitely use them again in the future, I see no need to spend more on Jazz pickups. I only have photos of the first fitting, with Wilkinsons' covers (just a few tiny rolls of double sided EVA tape stategically holding them in place and centered lengthwise). Fitting without the Wilkinson covers looks a little more ghetto (more EVA basically) but is as effective and secure. More foam at the bottom of cavities pushes pickups up. A clip of them, before 3D printed covers (just had some foam "frames" to keep stuff/dirt from getting in the cavities).

Bart pickups = hardest pass for me. As somebody else already said, better to look for Nordstrand equipped models.

A couple songs from iconic Argentinean bands, with my new Yammie SuperBass ❤️

SO easy to get there. Low setup helps. And this one has a substantial neck, the SBV sounds like this (just a tad less basss heavy, but as punchy and barking) and does indeed have a Geddy sig style skinny neck too. It's "easy Geddy 101" the moment I put any of these 2 Yammies on my lap. They just ask for it. Still, too cautious/insecure to attempt Rush covers 😅

And one more song, this time full open Jazz tone...

Quick song, on neck pickup...