-
Posts
8,068 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
85
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Shop
Articles
Everything posted by Stub Mandrel
-
I really hate to ask this, but... what strings for P bass?
Stub Mandrel replied to Bonzo's topic in Accessories and Misc
As supplied fitted to my Flea bass which I realise I have now had for 11 months played nearly every other day on average (I even managed to gig it once before lockdown!) and though not as bright as they were still sound passable. As our birthdays are only 12 days apart I think we should get treated to a new set 🙂 -
Genderising is weird, you imagine people frotting these things... But I christened my B2 the 'Deathburger' and any bitsa/make since that is a 'Deathburger'.
-
What are you listening to right now?
Stub Mandrel replied to Sarah5string's topic in General Discussion
Recommendation from my brother. Very retro but fresh as a daisy: -
What are you listening to right now?
Stub Mandrel replied to Sarah5string's topic in General Discussion
-
What are you listening to right now?
Stub Mandrel replied to Sarah5string's topic in General Discussion
There is just one piece of music for the hic et nunc: -
My thoughts on this continue to evolve. Learning other people's basslines is a good way to stretch my skills and develop my playing and understanding of music. Trying to come up with my own variations/ideas also helps me improve. In a band situation what matters is that solid foundation for what everyone else is doing, plus yes it does matter to get any signature bits right.
-
I really hate to ask this, but... what strings for P bass?
Stub Mandrel replied to Bonzo's topic in Accessories and Misc
Your first new strings will be important as they will sound good and tend to colour how you feel about other types you try later. For that reason alone I would suggest something like a set of 50-105 nickel roundwounds. It's a sort of happy reference point from which you can try heavier or lighter gauges, different constructions and different materials. Plus they will certainly sound good on a P and sound good for a decent amount of time. Brand new strings will sound great, but that will fade after a while. Some people say flatwounds never lose their tone, others say they never had it in the first place. Coated strings last a long time, but I would say pay less and get ordinary strings so you can experiment with a few types of string over time. I recommend nickel roundwounds because although they are not as bright sounding as stainless steel they will keep their tone for longer which is important for a beginner as you don't want to be changing too regularly. Roundwounds are likely to be bit easier to play and will give you a wider sonic pallet; you can wind back the tone to emulate the sound of flatwounds. Equally important is gauge. 50-105 or 45-105 is a good place to start, 110 or above can be a bit of hard work for a beginner. 100 or less is very loose and only suits some basses and playing styles. Consider buying 'hardly used' sets of strings from the classified. These will let you compare gauges and styles. Also, when trying new strings, start off with your amp's tone controls set more or less flat, then tweak to get the sound you want. Lots of people start with the bass right up (because they want a 'solid' sound) and then struggle to get a sound they like. -
That arrangement will more faithfully simulate an amp that distorts as you drive it harder. With the diodes in the feedback loop it's a much more compressed 'always on' effect.
-
There have been a surprising number of albums recorded in Lockdown, what had YOU come across that's worth a listen? Let's be positive and concentrate on those that seem to have worked! I know Hawkwind are not everyone's cup of tea but the response to the lockdown album Carnivorous seems to almost universally positive in that it's being praised as a high point. It's actually just three of the guys - Dave Brock, Richard Chadwick and relatively new recruit Magnus Martin. I like it, although personally I don't rate it as consistently good as The Machine Stops which I think was their best in a long time.
-
Decent video editing software for Windows
Stub Mandrel replied to Happy Jack's topic in General Discussion
I would have responded to that quote with "I'll have everything, please, except the EZ490." -
Will I bring total humiliation on myself by sharing this? It came with ten reeds, all the ones I've tried seem to sound different. It says to choose the best reed, how should I test them? I've been dipping them in water then trying to play high and low notes*. *I can sort of play penny whistle and recorder, my hope is that this won't be much different aside from the blowing bit...
-
I like that style too.
-
Has anyone played in a band with a sibling?
Stub Mandrel replied to Barking Spiders's topic in General Discussion
I've played with one of my brothers as a one off, we might do some folky stuff in the future. My other brother is way above my pay grade, long ago he did jam with my first band and it was epic, but logistics made it impractical for him to join (he lived 30 miles away and didn't have a car). We might all be living in the same town again for the first time in 40 years... anything's possible. -
Hi Ray Make sure you are signed in. When you can see a page of your tunage, select 'share' and the box that appears will have a copiable link. Or right-click the name of a song and copy the link. Then just paste the link here...
-
No I have no averseness to using Hertz, but I applaud the use of subjective explanations to help people understand what that means in the real world - after all the aim of the diagram is to relate real world instruments and perceptions to objective frequency bands. I'm just befuddled by the suggestion that the use of a subjective approach in order to aid understanding and make the subject accessible is wrong by default. The Beaufort scale, Mohs hardness scale, most market research and a large part of medical research into areas like pain, physical disability and mental health all depend on subjective scales and there is a huge literature on how effective such approaches can be and where they fall down. All that's missing here, I feel, is the research to validate the subjective descriptions. Perhaps you could give people a vocabulary to choose from (ordered randomly) then play them (randomly ordered) pieces of music and individual sounds and ask them to choose the word that applies to each. Done well and carefully controlled, this would give an objective idea of what subjective terms people associate naturally with different frequencies. It's worth noting that colour descriptions have a strong cultural bias (some rainforest people make no strong differentiation between 'blue and green'. Newton's 'blue and indigo' were closer to what we call cyan and blue) so essentially they are learnt even though we tend to think red and blue (for example) are pretty objective concepts. I suspect it would be much easier to 'train' your ear to associate a given frequency band with a mnemonic like 'honk' than directly with a range of frequencies, the relation between mnemonic and frequency can then be learned to facilitate the use of things like graphic equalisers and parametric equalisers. In fact, I'm pretty sure that this is the way it works already - we don't instinctively recognise 'honk'* but we develop an understanding of it by listening to others use words describe sounds. *Actually a poor choice because I think true 'honk' suggests a mid-range sound that varies in harmonic content, dynamics and maybe even base frequency.
-
But so what? How else do you explain what its sounds like to someone who hasn't got a Fourier analyser and the knowledge to use it?
-
Another interesting isolated bass track - Sir Duke
Stub Mandrel replied to pobrien_ie's topic in General Discussion
"But that's your job!" -
Why so many short scale basses at the moment?
Stub Mandrel replied to Greg Edwards69's topic in Bass Guitars
I'm not convinced string length makes any overwhelming difference when we are talking such small differences. Whether I play Bb on the e-string sixth fret or a-string first fret on a standard bass the difference in sound is very subtle. Yet the difference in the vibrating string length and gauge are significantly bigger than between a 34" and 28" scale basses. The short scale bass may be lighter, but it's also going to be considerably stiffer (stiffness varies by the third power of length, other things being equal) so with the right choice of string gauge it could actually be brighter sounding. After all, who has noticed guitars (or mandolins) that lack brightness... -
What are you listening to right now?
Stub Mandrel replied to Sarah5string's topic in General Discussion
-
Basically, yes.
-
How do I 'learn the frequencies' as I don't have perfect pitch? The only practical answer is some sort of subjective guide to how sounds translate into frequencies, which is what that graphic tries to do. Every book I've read on sound engineering (OK only two) and most websites uses similar terms to try and help you translate what you hear into what frequencies to adjust. Put it this way... would you think your Lighting Engineer was being more objective if he said 'Increase the 550nm light source' if you asked for a green spotlight?