Your question is good, I think it's more a personal preference and taste than a question of genre or style.
If I have to record a bass line for a track, I used to make it with a JB and this Modern as well, and the customer/engineer/producer decide which sound would be preferred. Sometimes I choose one of them directly when I'm sure which one will be suit for the actual song (last time f.e. used the JB for a RHCP style song)
Tom Hamilton is another big name for these basses:
https://reverb.com/item/65442283-sadowsky-tom-hamilton-s-aerosmith-metro-5-string-bass-brown-sunburst