[quote name='neilp' timestamp='1446811535' post='2902511']
McCartney doesn't count. Even if he died today, everything he's ever done has "trite" and "banal" and "cliche-ridden" stamped all over it in 20-foot letters. Iconic? Never was, never will be IMHO
[/quote]
You are at liberty to hold said opinion and to express it, as you have done, but to say "everything he's ever done has "trite" and "banal" and "cliche-ridden" stamped all over it in 20-foot letters". Really?
[quote name='neilp' timestamp='1446817438' post='2902606']
With respect, what's bizzarre about it? Frogs Chorus? Mull of Kintyre? Band on the Run? All the most insipid Beatles output? Please.... A competent bass player, just about
Look up Jack Bruce's views on McCartney.
[/quote]
Well, one bizarre thing, IMHO, is citing [i]The Frog Chorus[/i], a popular song specially written for a children's film, as an example of the "banality" of "everything he's ever done etc...". The same goes for citing [i]Mull of Kintyre[/i], an extremely popular love song to his home in Scotland. I realise it may be an unpopular view with some but I really don't at all see what's wrong with a musician-songwriter writing popular songs.
As for calling [i]Band on the Run[/i] insipid. Again, really? And there is a long list of not "trite, banal, cliche-ridden". But if you don't like it then so be it.