[quote name='cheddatom' timestamp='1441623951' post='2860277']
... I don't think you learn how to write music by playing covers in a pub ...
[/quote]
I'd say that very little creativity (if any at all) comes from nothing. Only God supposedly creates [i]ex nihilo[/i].
For songwriting, it might not be actually playing covers in a pub but - at least generally speaking - it will involve deep immersion in some way in already existing songs and in most cases they will be the base material from which the new is constructed.
John Lennon said of ELO's Showdown:
[quote]On September 28, 1974, John Lennon was a guest of Dennis Elsas on WNEW-FM, a New York City radio station, where he commented that if the Beatles had stayed together, they would sound like ELO on [i]Showdown[/i], calling them the "Son of Beatles."
"We're gonna play Electric Light Orchestra from last year, [i]Showdown[/i], which I thought was a great record and I was expecting it to be #1 but I don't think UA [United Artists] got their fingers out and pushed it. And it's a nice group -- I call them 'Son of Beatles' -- although they're doing things we never did, obviously. But I remember a statement they made when they first formed was to carry on from where the Beatles left off with [i]Walrus[/i], and they certainly did. And for those people who like to know where licks and things come from, which I do.... this is a beautiful combination of [i]I Heard It Through The Grapevine[/i] by Marvin Gaye and [i]Lightning Strikes Again[/i] Lou Christie, and it's a beautiful job with a little [i]Walrus[/i] underneath." [url="http://www.jefflynnesongs.com/showdown/"]Source[/url] [/quote]
[media]http://youtu.be/QB9MgpxF4HQ[/media]
On the same radio show Lennon talks about the influence of bluebeat/ska on the middle eight of The Beatles [i]I Call Your Name[/i] - [url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QiZHkhqQWaE"]https://www.youtube....h?v=QiZHkhqQWaE[/url]