[quote name='geoham' timestamp='1499721553' post='3333196']
I'm a huge fan of Roger's, so perhaps a bit biased!
I love the album. My view is that it's deliberately a bit 'Floyd by numbers' in order to appeal to as wide an audience as possible, and spread his political message as wide as possible. Also, he's been promising the fans an album (the Heartland project was mentioned by him and he was often asked about it) for about 10 years.
I personally know some Floyd fans that don't like Roger's solo stuff - but do like the new album.
I loved his last album, Amused To Death - but I feel I'm in the minority!
In my view, in the past 15 years or so, Roger has been addressing his reputation of making self indulgent, often dreary records and reminding people he was the creative force behind Pink Floyd's most successful albums. A key point for me is that the two 'demo' songs he released in the early 2000's (Leaving Beiruit and To Kill The Child) are nowhere to be seen now.
I think this is his way of giving the mainstream fans what they want.
[/quote]
Yep, it's definitely more concise than he's been in decades. Some of the musical moments are truly breathtaking.