[quote name='BenTunnicliffe' timestamp='1375897002' post='2167146']
With all these arguments FOR the custom J + Ps I definitely still think that in what I see top flight session guys and gals using and in general at shows there does still seem to be far more people playing either straight ahead relic Fenders and boutique, super modern custom designs (Like my Overwater perception) and much less people going out there with the kind of classic-bass-updated designs we're talking about.
[/quote]
I can identify with this to some extent. I recently sold a Sadowsky and bought a '62 RI Jazz. To the non-anorak, they looked remarkably similar but I found I couldn't get a true vintage Jazz sound out of the Sadowsky. My MTD covers modern tones so the bass was not being used. This pairing suits me better.
Having said that, if I had money for another good bass, I must admit I would love a good 5 string Jazz with a retro appearance. I was very taken by the passive Nordy 5 that was on here a week or so back. Alas, that will have to wait a while.