For me it's simple. The 62's produce the P sound I'm familiar with from umpteen recordings. They just sound right (in every sense... tone, bite, output, warmth). I play rock, indie, blues, motown and the 62's nail that. But if you play funk and modern, than 62's are not right for that sound. In fact, a jazz bass would be more suitable, with "modern" voiced pickups.
As the OP was comparing two "vintage" voiced pickups, as said by many of us, the 62 rules, imho.