Jump to content
Why become a member? ×

sub bass


herbercham
 Share

Recommended Posts

Hi all

Embarking on a liquid funk project, I am using an oc-2 for my subs, lowpassed at 80hz.

Correct me if i'm wrong, but the oc-2 outputs a (sort of) square wave. Well, sounds like it to my ears, anyway. The thing is, once the 'highs' are cut from the oc-2, it loses the tonal charm that makes it so desirable, and the subs aren't as solid as, say, a sine or even triangle wave.

So does anyone have any better ideas for an analogue octave pedal that will provide more convincing subs?

Thanks guys

Link to comment
Share on other sites

http://youtu.be/ecy9AgFqKH0

Godlyke Great Divide: http://www.godlyke.com/totally-wycked-audio-effects-pedals/hand-built/great-divide-2-analog-synth-octaver

Mantic Density Hulk: http://www.manticeffects.com/products/density-hulk
http://www.manticeffects.com/products/density-hulk-pro

DOD are also supposed to be reissuing their Meatbox pedal.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Low passing at 80hz & it loses it's tonal charm? That's weird. :yarr:
You could split your signal, keep the 80hz filter on one channel & have a notch filter on the other set somewhere around 3-400hz to bring some tone back (play with the notch frequency to get your sound).
Failing that, there's the Pigtronix Mothership or the Guyatone MOM5 for sine wave lows.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='dannybuoy' timestamp='1396477827' post='2414261']
Grammar - it's the difference between knowing your pants, and knowing you're pants.
[/quote]

I'm slightly concerned...

Why does your grandma know your pants?

:P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Aguilar Octamizer is very good for subs as it has the filter built in, and isn't huge enough to destroy your amp.
The Density Hulk is also killer, but I don't recommend sending it to your amp/cab as to get it at volume it puts mega strain on your gear. If you play shows without PA support, then the Aggie is my weapon of choice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='herbercham' timestamp='1396472243' post='2414178']
The thing is, once the 'highs' are cut from the oc-2, it loses the tonal charm that makes it so desirable, and the subs aren't as solid as, say, a sine or even triangle wave.
[/quote]

You'll not get much charm or character from anything low-passed at 80Hz. A/B it with an MXR BOD, Aguilar Octamizer etc and I doubt you'll see much difference honestly. Those pedals are all largely the same engine, just with different control sets.

If you're processing the subs separately you can make it as simple or as complex as you like. As mentioned, the Density Hulk is ideal for this but can be an amp killer, but there are ways round it. Look at how proper PAs are designed, and the subs will be high-passed and limited to avoid damage to amps and speakers - that would obviously add more gear though...

What cabs are you using? This will be pretty key too. My BFM cabs and most Barefaced cabs are designed and built to handle audio that low, but cabs I've had or used previously would struggle.

Good luck with it :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

wow thanks for the responses guys!

never even heard of the density hulk!

I should have given a more detailed description really. I am not fussed about losing the 'tonal charm' from the oc-2, I just mean that the reason I have held onto it no longer applies in my current setup- hence the search for a different sub.

To be honest, my home gear is embarrassingly poor. I play into a laptop- one usb midi input for mids/ highs in NI massive, one 1/4" analogue for subs. Splitting duties between midi/analogue in this way seems to be quite effective, but its still very early days. The laptop is where I do the lowpassing/ highpassing (at around 30hz)/ compressing etc. in the Reaper DAW, so the octaver is the only (non-midi) pedal I use.

At the moment I just listen through headphones out of the external sound card. No gigs, no studio practices- I'm still trying to figure it all out. I know that without listening through decent cabs its all a bit academic. Still, even though I am using headphones, other subs, say, from Massive or produced tracks, sound better, thicker, more solid. And I am guessing its down to the waveform. Does this seem likely? Square waves aren't so great for thick subs, are they? And the oc-2 is kinda squarey, isn't it?

Assuming it is down to the waveform, does anyone know what sort of waveforms the octavers mentioned above generate, or how they are generated? Or maybe its just a case of trial and error...

Thanks again everyone!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

[quote name='Meddle' timestamp='1396550572' post='2415053']
Maybe not what you are after but... from memory the OC-2 is an analogue 'flip flop' divider circuit. It produces a sine wave (or some other simple wave), then filters it to make it sound less synthy. If you check out synth mods for the pedal it actually sounds pretty wild.
[/quote]

I've got a synth-modded unit (and two other OC-2s, all three on my board!) and unfiltered it sounds to me somewhere between a square and a sawtooth. It's a bit too gnarly to be a regular square.

The only problem with cutting the filters out of the circuit is you have to play much cleaner to make it usable. I tend to filter it with a treadle and just let it peak out for fills and legato stuff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Analog octave pedals do produce a square wave at 1/2 the fundamental frequency of your note. But they then use this to invert the original signal. Half of the squarewave is normal signal. Half of it is turned upside down.

This means that the effected sound retains some of the character of your bass's tone (you can tell this by turning your treble knob up or down - you can hear the result in the octave effect), but which also has a strong octave down component.

It also means that the effect follows the volume of your bass's signal, both overall and as each note dies away.

After the squarewave is applied, they usually do some filtering to remove the rough edges - some, like thisnameistaken's synth modded OC-2 or the EHX Octave Multiplexer let you control the filtering.

The Meatbox and the Density Hulk clones also do this trick, but use a specific chip to do the work which sounds smoother, and they have additional low filters to help boost the bass.

Another type of pedal to have a look at are bass enhancers like the Aphex Xciter. I have one somewhere - it makes the bottom end thicker and more plasticky. I think it works by phase aligning different harmonics within the signal. It also does exciting which is adding extra high frequency harmonics.

If you want to play with waveforms, check out the Iron Ether Subterranea. Mine arrived two days ago. It gives you an octave down with adjustable filter (sounds cleaner than the synth mod OC2 to my ears), plus octave down and normal octave synth waveforms - square, pulse and triangle that you can mix together - sounds great into my Iron Ether Xerograph low pass filter. Video here:

[url="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-mcop5MFUo%5B/media"]http://www.youtube....cop5MFUo[/url]

Edited by phagor
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the Aphex alignment trickery just applies to the top end, the 'big bottom' circuit is some kind of bass boost with a limiter to compress the lows I think. But yes, it does the job very well, and might be just the ticket if you just want to fatten up an OC-2.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Also consider that you may just want to look at your EQ.
P-Bass, tone all the way down, take a look at the old Boss PQ-3B which can adjust down to 25hz (technically lower than the Meatbox), boost that.
Or the newer MXR Kerry King EQ, goes down to 31hz.
Put some modulation on if you want some movement, but yeah, easy :)

Si

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you are playing into a Laptop anyway, and using filters on the laptop then I'm not sure you need to worry about other plugins. Stick with your OC-2 and get a decent plugin designed to turn bass into BASS. Something like Renaissance Bass form 'Waves'. I have it and use it on Kick drums and synth bass when I make electronic music as it sounds decking huge. If you are processing via software then I see no reason to do this over changing the pedals at your feet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorted!

Very interesting to find out how these gadgets work. I'll keep hold of the oc-2 for the time being then, and check out this Renaissance plugin.

Thanks so much to all of you, I am humbled to have access to your bank of collective knowledge! It has been an education.

Take it easy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...