godin sd4 vs yamaha bb424

[zonular]

Gwan which would would you opt for.
I've been debating a p or pj bass to add to the stable, tried a yammy tbrx 305 didn't like the b, tried a cort/ibanez didn't like the b so ill stick to the four banger for the moment. I've seen two of these p/j basses s/h which is the one to go with?

[Gnermo]

Not sure if you've got something, but I have the Godin SD4 and it's pretty great.
Lightweight, fast neck and has good features like string-through body.

[prowla]

There's something to be said for not having animated avatars on the site!

[wingnutkj]

Can't go far wrong with either of them - I've got an SD which is *still* my go-to bass (admittedly, I swapped the body out for a P-shaped one years ago), and my mate swears by the Yammys, owns two and is always on the lookout for more.

Have you tried them both out? I've not seen an SD in a shop in years!