Jump to content
Why become a member? ×

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have decided it is time to replace my old Ibanez Talman Bass and wondering what is the cheapest and best value for money bass i can get i tried to get a Harley Benton PB-20 SBK to discover that it will not arrive until late February what should i get?

Posted

The talman is all right but just is uncomfortable for me as the cutout is the wrong place for my leg, although about the J&D basses would you say that are they are good for the price?

Posted (edited)

The normal (not SBK) PB-20 seems to be in stock.  I had one for a while and it's good.

I also still have a J&D, although mine's the mini jazz , not the precision (this or perhaps this).

I play my J&D every now and then at gigs and it's good.  In fact I got a really nice compliment on my tone recently from the singer, whereas with my Sandberg no one's ever said a thing!
 

Edited by jrixn1
Posted
47 minutes ago, AMD8806 said:

The talman is all right but just is uncomfortable for me as the cutout is the wrong place for my leg, although about the J&D basses would you say that are they are good for the price?

Play standing up?

Posted

For under £100, go second hand. You'll pretty much only get trash for £100 brand new that will be worth £50 at best the second you've bought it.

If you buy pre-owned, and buy smart, you can get something half decent, and if you don't like it after a week or two you can sell it on and break even or maybe make a few pennies which can be reinvested in another second hand bass where the cycle can continue!

I did this with amps for about a year until I finally settled on something I really liked. Gives you a great chance to try what's out there without really spending anything other that your initial outlay.

  • Like 2
Posted

J&D are very, very good, if my £113 Thinline Tele copy is any indication. What's very interesting is that it's possibly to buy the exact same guitar, obviously from the same production line, with a slightly more Fender-shaped headstock bearing a "Tokai" logo. Costs about 3 times the price of mine.

I'd have no hesitation in picking up a J&D Precision or Jazz copy for around the £100 mark, same goes for Harley Benton, from everything I've heard.

The idea of cheap instruments inevitably being junk really is a thing of the past. Hail China!

  • Like 2
Posted

Revelations are as good as anything I’ve tried new in that sort of price range (well, slightly higher, but worth it).

Secondhand, you could do worse than a Yamaha. Pretty much any one  

 

Posted
1 hour ago, owen said:

I must admit I have never picked up a Yamaha and thought anything but "yep, that will do the job nicely".

Yep, for a ton used nothing would beat a Yammy RBX170. Saw one go for 67 quid on ebay last week actually. 

Posted

Anything under a ton is likely to be a sideways move, really. The Yamaha referred to above is good for the money, but if you could save up a bit more - say another £100 - you could make a more worthwhile improvement.

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

I personally believe that we are living in the golden age of lutherie. It is very difficult to buy a poor instrument now. Pickups generally are the weak spot, but even then they are not rubbish. I just got 2 J&D Jazz basses for work for £125 and they are fine and dandy. I could happily gig them. They are slightly heavy and the Poly on them is nice and thick, but I think that is the norm until you spend quite a bit more. I think you have to climb much higher than another £100 to get anything that is appreciably better.

Dan, on reading it this again, my post could seem as if I am disagreeing with you in a forum/troll stylee and that was not my intention.

Edited by owen
  • Like 4
Posted (edited)
13 hours ago, owen said:

I personally believe that we are living in the golden age of lutherie. It is very difficult to buy a poor instrument now. Pickups generally are the weak spot, but even then they are not rubbish. I just got 2 J&D Jazz basses for work for £125 and they are fine and dandy. I could happily gig them. They are slightly heavy and the Poly on them is nice and thick, but I think that is the norm until you spend quite a bit more. I think you have to climb much higher than another £100 to get anything that is appreciably better.

I usually buy the best I can but at the moment I have three basses, all worth no more than £250, and furnished with pickups costing no more than £30. They all do a great job. Most remarkable is the Entwhistle p bass pup on my Revelation (£199 new). which punches way way above its £12 weight.  

Edited by lownote12
  • Like 2
Posted
1 hour ago, lownote12 said:

I usually buy the best I can but at the moment I have three basses, all worth no more than £250, and furnished with pickups costing no more than £30. They all do a great job. Most remarkable ia the Entwhistle p bass pup on my Revelation (£199 new). which punches way way above its £12 weight.  

Entwistle pickups are ace - they can make an OK bass sound great for a pocket-money price. 

As long as the neck is decent, with an action you can cope with and fret ends that don't lacerate your hands if you dare to do a glissando, £100 will buy you something more than adequate. Your options are wider if you're handy with a soldering iron, too. Westfield basses are worth a look - they crop up fairly regularly second hand for well under £100 and I think they're every bit as good as a Chinese Squier. With the money you save, you might consider upgrading the tuners and the pick-up, but they're good basses, straight from the factory. failing that, here's another vote for a Yamaha - their "entry level" instruments are really good. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...