Comparing three basses

[ped]

I just recorded this clip. I tried for ages to get it so that the song played and the basses switched between as you go through but I gave up in the end. There's a few mistakes and so on but it should give a fairly good idea of how they sound. 

 

 

 

[Munurmunuh]

My wretched opinon: favourite would probably be no.1 were it strung with rounds, but as things are I'll say, aren't Stingrays wonderful for music like this?

 

ps After more listens back and forth, no.1 is my favourite, despite the flats  Love the depth of the tone. 

Edited August 12, 2021 by Ricky Rioli

[Reggaebass]

The stingray sounds lush slapped 

[ped]

I’m listening back and I’m embarrassed by all the mistakes!! I might do it again. 
 

Yeah each bass has it’s place. I have three ‘play along’ playlists on Spotify, one for each bass

[Munurmunuh]

PS love the unexpected major third at 1'14" 😃

[ped]

Just now, Ricky Rioli said:

PS love the unexpected major third at 1'14" 😃

Made me wince 🥲

[Marvin]

I preferred the Celinder out of the 3. Then the MM and finally the G&L. I wasn't that taken with the G&L for the track, it didn't fit for me.

 

Rest assured though, I was oblivious to the mistakes...probably

[Munurmunuh]

39 minutes ago, ped said:

Made me wince 🥲

 

False relations, an important part of the English style once upon a time, very delicious 😊

[SurroundedByManatees]

I think the Celinder sound fits the track best, but like them all actually.🙂

[Pukie]

Knew I was going to like the Celinder best before even watching….. it didn’t disappoint.

[Happypants]

Between the Celinder and the Stingray for me as the track suits them better. Probably the Stingray if I was pushed and probably helped by the colour!

[40hz]

Stingray, by a wide margin!

Edited August 12, 2021 by 40hz

[OliverBlackman]

I liked the stingray best. What would be interesting is how different they’d all sound if someone else was playing them because you seem to have a very soft touch ped. I know that if I played the same stingray with the setup I like it wouldn’t be the same.

[PlungerModerno]

G&L SB-1 sounds best to my ears, even if the other two are richer in the highs they're getting on top of the sticky guitar groove too much for my taste, if the bass level was lowered / EQ'd a little in those frequencies I think it would lose a lot of the bite. Flats win for my ears in that mix, and the P-like mids are hard to argue against.

 

Nice.

[Doctor J]

Wot, no Vigier?

[Lozz196]

12 hours ago, SurroundedByManatees said:

I think the Celinder sound fits the track best, but like them all actually.🙂

Same here, it seemed to support the track better

[ped]

10 minutes ago, Doctor J said:

Wot, no Vigier?

 
Currently awaiting new strings. Once they arrive I’ll do a new video and put a bit more effort into it 

[LukeFRC]

I liked the black ones best.
The G&L reminds me of when I stuck chromes on my L1000 - which I didn’t like! So even though it sounds fine that makes the ceilinder the winner for me. 
interesting to see the different rh positions fingerstyle too
 

not that it was a competition or anyone would care about what I think! 

[uk_lefty]

Stingray sounds best to me but I am biased because I have a Stingray for that "stingy" gritty but in the high notes that is unmistakably Stingray. 

 

None are bad basses, all fit the style to me, but the Ray has its own very distinct personality. I did like the Celinder too though. 

[ped]

Quite interesting to hear how divided opinions are on which sounds best for this groove  👍🏼
 

[ezbass]

They all sound good, but I think the cut and punch of the 'Ray lifts it to the top position.

[MGBrown]

G&L 1st

Celinder 2nd

Ray 3rd

 

The G&L sits so well with other instruments. It's dirty & funky. A touch too much sparkle on the other two demands too much attention and they sit too high in the mix though maybe some eq would help.  

[Old Horse Murphy]

Stingray for me. A bit more fizz and nice depth too

[ped]

Every time someone says their fave I go back to listen and think “yeah me too”

 

…until someone says a different one, then I do the same again 😆

[ezbass]

2 hours ago, ped said:

Every time someone says their fave I go back to listen and think “yeah me too”

 

…until someone says a different one, then I do the same again 😆

It depends what you’re wanting from it. Each of them does something different and if that’s the thing you’re looking for it’s the best. After reading @MGBrown’s comment, I went back and had yet another listen and the low down, solid sound of the G&L is beguiling, I really like it (it’s not unlike my Mustang, which I’m massively in love with currently). I like the ‘Ray for the added bit of nasal midrange that makes it sit well, but still stand out (if that makes sense) in that track. The Celinder, unsurprisingly, has elements of both the ‘Ray and the G&L due to its J bass DNA, which, to my ears, makes it less distinctive. Ultimately, as I opened with, it’s down to what you’re looking for, which leads to each of them being the best for a given set of parameters. If I heard any one of them on a recording or in a live setting, my ears would be happy.